Publication Ethics Statement

Publication Ethics

Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance, we are dedicated to upholding the highest standards of publication ethics in order to foster a responsible and ethical research environment. Our commitment lies not only in disseminating valuable knowledge but also in maintaining integrity, transparency, and ethical behavior throughout the publication process. To ensure this, we have developed comprehensive publication ethics guidelines, which adhere to the principles set forth by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance is dedicated to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics to create a responsible and ethical research environment. We are committed to not only sharing valuable knowledge but also upholding integrity, transparency, and ethical conduct throughout the publication process. To ensure this, we have developed comprehensive publication ethics guidelines that align with the principles established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Ethical Issues arising in scholarly publishing

  • Plagiarism
  • AI detection
  • Redundant publication (dual publication)
  • Self-plagiarism (sometimes known as text recycling)
  • Authorship issues
  • Coercive citation
  • Defamation/libel
  • Fabricated data
  • Unethical research and testing
  • Conflicts of interest

Basic principles

Authors submitting works to Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance warrant the following:

  • Their article/chapter is original;
  • The work has not been submitted elsewhere and is not under consideration with any other publication;
  • The work does not include libelous, defamatory, or unlawful statements;
  • Permission has been cleared for any third-party material included;
  • Proof of consent has been obtained for any named individuals or organizations;
  • Authorship has been agreed upon prior to submission, and no one has been ‘gifted' authorship or denied credit as an author ("ghost authorship”).

Authors submitting works to Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance publications do so on the understanding that if it is discovered that these basic principles have not been adhered to, action will be taken following the COPE guidelines and may result in one of the following correction notices.

Erratum: This generally refers to a production error, which has been introduced during the publication process. If an erratum is issued, it will appear on the abstract of the online version of the paper to ensure full visibility. The erratum will also appear in the hard copy of the next volume or issue of the publication.

Corrigendum: This generally refers to an author error or oversight prior to the paper's submission to the publication. If a corrigendum is issued, it will appear on the abstract of the online version of the paper to ensure full visibility. The corrigendum will also appear in the hard copy of the next volume or issue of the publication.

Retraction notice: A retraction notice will be issued in serious cases of ethical misconduct or where the research is seriously flawed and misleading. In normal circumstances, the paper will remain in the online version of the journal or book. A retraction notice will appear on the online version of the paper. The retraction notice will also appear in the hard copy of the next volume or issue of the publication.

Note of clarification: A note of clarification will be used when a point needs to be emphasized or clarified in the text, but it does not constitute a correction. Please note that any correction has to be highlighted as a stated erratum, corrigendum, or note of clarification, and the text cannot be amended. This is to make sure that the reader is aware of any changes to the text that they might have cited or referred to in their subsequent research or practice.

Expression of concern: In cases where a conclusion is unclear or where we are unable to make a fair decision due to conflicts of interest or lack of information, we will publish an expression of concern regarding the paper. An expression of concern will appear on the online version of the paper at the abstract level to ensure visibility for all readers, including non-subscribers.

Please note that for legal reasons or when an article or chapter forms evidence in an independent hearing, we may not be able to take action until all matters have been fully resolved.

In addition, please note that Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance reserves the right to not proceed with a case if the complainant presents a false name or affiliation or acts in an inappropriate or threatening manner towards Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance editors and staff.

 

Plagiarism

One of the Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance core values is originality; therefore, we did not tolerate any article that has plagiarism issues. We use Turnitin as our plagiarism screening tool to ensure that our article is free from plagiarism issues. The manuscript is passed if the similarity is less than 25%. The result of the preliminary check for plagiarism is forwarded to the Section Editor.  Plagiarism may also be identified during the review and revision processes. So, the final plagiarism will be done after the author finalizes their reviewed manuscript. 

When plagiarism is identified, the Section Editor is responsible for reviewing the manuscript, and the Editor-in-Chief will agree on measures according to the plagiarism detected in the manuscript in agreement with the following guidelines. The Editor-in-Chief has the authority to deviate from these guidelines on a case-by-case basis. 

AI Detection

Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance applies a maximum limit of 30% AI detection score in the manuscript review process. This aims to ensure that the submitted work is the original result of the author and not fully generated by artificial intelligence (AI). Manuscripts that exceed the AI detection limit will be immediately rejected to evaluate the level of AI engagement and compliance with publication ethical standards.

Redundant publication (also known as dual publication)

Authors are expected to submit original, previously unpublished content to Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance publications. It is an unacceptable academic practice to submit to more than one journal at the same time. Authors are expected to wait until receiving a decision from one journal before submitting to the next.

Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance will follow the Committee on Publication Ethics' flowcharts in cases of alleged redundant publication in submitted or published articles.

Text recycling (sometimes known as self-plagiarism)

Authors are expected to submit original content to Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance publications. It is only acceptable for research to be repeated if it leads to different or new conclusions or for comparisons with new data. In all cases, it is important to reference the previously published work.
If any element of the work has been published previously, you must ensure that this work is fully referenced and state it at the point of submission so that the Editor may make a fully informed decision.

Authorship issues

In multi-authored papers, it is important that all authors who have made a significant contribution to the paper are listed. Those who have provided support but have not contributed to the research should be acknowledged in an Acknowledgements section.

Authorship issues fall into three main types:

  1. The exclusion of a contributor from the list of authors
  2. The inclusion of a named person who has not contributed to the paper or does not wish to be associated with the research
  3. The order of the authors on the paper and the level of contribution that they have made to the paper.

Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance will endeavor to facilitate a resolution to an authorship dispute. However, as the research process is undertaken prior to the paper being submitted to Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance, it is not possible for Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance or the editors to comment on the level of contribution by each author. Please refer to the Committee on Publication Ethics' flowcharts for the processes that Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Financefollows in cases of authorship disputes in submitted or published articles.

If the matter cannot be resolved, Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance will refer the matter to the authors' institutions.

If all authors agree to a change to authorship on a paper, this will be presented as a corrigendum. A retraction notice will only be published when requested by all authors.

Coercive citation

During the peer review process, it is typical for authors to be directed by reviewers to papers that further develop and improve the author's ideas.

Whilst there may be legitimate occasions where it is necessary to reference other publications, Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance regards ‘coercive citation' (i.e., where a reference is included as a condition of acceptance or without academic justification) as unethical and does not condone this kind of behavior.

Defamation/libel

Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance requires that authors obtain written "proof of consent" for studies about named organizations or people.

If inaccurate, unsubstantiated, or emotive statements are made about organizations or people in a submitted paper, Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance reserves the right to request changes to the text from the author or to reject the paper prior to publication.

Critiques and reviews of products and services are acceptable, but comments must be constructive and must not be made maliciously.
If statements have been made in a paper that is published by Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance and found to be defamatory, a retraction notice will be published. In some cases and when legally required, the paper will be withdrawn from the online version of the journal or book. An apology will be published in a forthcoming issue of the journal or volume of the book.

Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance will advise all authors of case studies to inform the subject (person or organization) and to seek permission. If Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance considers that the study could be potentially libelous, we will require written proof of consent before placing the paper into the production process.

Fabricated data

Please refer to the Committee on Publication Ethics' flowcharts for the processes that Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance follows in cases of fabricated data in submitted or published articles. As the research is conducted prior to the paper being submitted to an Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance journal or book, it is not possible for Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance or the editors to adjudicate in all cases. We will endeavor to facilitate a resolution and will refer the matter to the authors' institutions when appropriate.

Conflict of interest

All conflicts of interest should be declared by the author, editor, or reviewer.
In all cases, Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance will:

  1. Act professionally and efficiently.
  2. Be fair and objective.
  3. Always approach the accused party to establish their position before making a decision or committing to a course of action.
  4. Ensure that we provide sufficient time for all parties to respond.
  5. Keep all parties informed of decisions, including the copyright owners, editors, and authors.
  6. As members of the Committee on Publication Ethics, follow the processes highlighted in the flowcharts presented by COPE.
  7. It is Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance's responsibility to protect authors' moral rights (to be acknowledged as the author and not to be misrepresented) and to ensure the correct record of the literature.

Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance reserves the right to withdraw and rescind any acceptance should a case of ethical misconduct be discovered prior to publication.
It will not be possible to please all parties in every case. Following a fair and considered process, the final decision in any disputed case will rest with the editor and Asian Journal of Law and Islamic Finance.